Embassy Newsletter
Washington DC November 13,
1997
Holbrooke Conducts Round of Informal
Talks on Cyprus
Calls Cyprus Settlement “Core
Issue” of Regional
Stability
Despite great differences in the positions of
the parties, the U.S. will continue its efforts since a
Cyprus settlement is key to defusing regional tensions,
U.S. Special Presidential Emissary for Cyprus Richard
Holbrooke said in Nicosia on November
11.
During his first visit to Cyprus since
President Clinton appointed him earlier in the year to
lead U.S. efforts on Cyprus, Holbrooke first met
separately with Cyprus President Glafcos Clerides and
Turkish Cypriot leader Rauf Denktash on November 10 and
then held a joint four and one-half hour meeting with
Clerides and Denktash on November
11.
The differences between the parties “are
very profound,” Holbrooke said afterwards, adding
that “on their publicly stated positions, the two
sides have incompatible positions on two or three central
issues,” such as sovereignty and “the right
of refugees to return.” On sovereignty,
the Turkish position remains outside the U.N. framework,
while the Turkish side also rejects the right of all
refugees to return to their homes, as called for in
numerous U.N. resolutions.
The U.S. will continue its efforts to achieve
regional peace because the area is “critical to
stability for the U.S. national security and the
Europeans,” Ambassador Holbrooke
said.
He also expressed concern over on-going
military tensions between Greece and Turkey since
“stability is an essential goal in the post cold
war period and in my view the other issues between Greece
and Turkey cannot be dealt with unless Cyprus is dealt
with centrally, it is the core
issue.”
Reiterating that the Cyprus government welcomes
the U.S. initiative, which he said was “serious and
dynamic,” government spokesman Manolis Christofides
said on November 13 that “with the U.S. leading
international interest for a settlement to the Cyprus
problem, we believe the U.N. has at its disposal the
dynamism needed to proceed towards a
solution.”
The meeting between Clerides and Denktash was
“very candid and intense . . . there were no
substantive results, nor did we expect any,” the
U.S. State Department spokesman said on November 12,
adding that “the purpose of these meetings was to
keep the process going, keep both sides talking and
create opportunities for
progress.”
Holbrooke, accompanied by the State Department
Special Cyprus Coordinator Tom Miller, met with Turkish
Prime Minister Mesut Yilmaz and other Turkish officials
on November 12, while on November 13 he discussed
international efforts on Cyprus with Greek Foreign
Affairs Underscretary Kranidiotis and E.U. External
Affairs Commissioner Hans Van den
Broek.
On November 18 the U.N. Secretary-General's
Special Advisor on Cyprus, Diego Cordovez, arrives in
Cyprus to further explore the positions of the parties in
an effort to narrow the differences between the parties
prior to a resumption of direct talks, to take
place next year.
Turkish Provocations
Continue
The Holbrooke visit followed weeks of growing
regional tension during October and early November, as
Turkey harassed Cyprus government defense exercises and
repeatedly violated Cyprus’ sovereign airspace and
territorial waters.
Turkey continued with these provocations
despite warnings by the international community, and
particularly by the United Nations and the United States,
that efforts should be made to reduce tensions and that
Turkey’s provocations run counter to its public
profession of peace.
These tensions intensified in early November,
when Turkey’s illegal occupation forces began a
series of mock military attacks. Turkey’s massive
display of force included the docking of a flotilla of
naval vessels in ports in occupied Cyprus, and
transporting tanks and additional military hardware to
occupied Cyprus.
Turkey’s provocations underscored the
importance of Cyprus acquiring an antiaircraft defense
system, Cyprus President Glafcos Clerides said on October
16, so that Cyprus “will never become a Turkish
colony.” While continuing to propose the
complete demilitarization of Cyprus, Clerides added on
October 14 that in light of Turkey’s continuing
invasion, the Cyprus government has both the right and
obligation to bolster its defenses “as long as
Turkey launches threats against
Cyprus.”
“Turkey's military presence in occupied
Cyprus, already very strong, creates tension,”
Cyprus Foreign Minister Ioannis Kasoulides said on
October 27, in expressing his concern over the fact that
Ankara was sending additional equipment into an area the
U.N. Secretary-General has already called “one of
the most militarized areas in the
world.”
The Cyprus government protested to the U.N.
over “an alarmingly increasing number of violations
of the airspace of the Republic of Cyprus and of the
Nicosia FIR (Flight Information Region) by military
aircraft of the Turkish Air Force.” The government
emphasized that “such overflights increase
political tension on the island and undermine efforts
towards achieving” a final Cyprus
settlement.
In an outrageous display of aggression, Turkish
jets also harassed the aircraft that brought Greek
Defense Minister Akis Tsohatzopoulos to and from
Cyprus.
On October 20 State Department Spokesman James
Rubin called these reports “disturbing,” and
stressed that “if Turkish aircraft flew
provocatively close to the Greek defense minister’s
aircraft, such action would not be consistent with
Turkey’s stated desire to reduce tension with
Greece.” He also called on the parties to
“avoid steps that complicate or detract from
efforts to promote dialogue and
negotiations.”
“The large-scale maneuvers of Turkish
troops practicing sea and air landings, firing and other
operations, give rise to doubt that they are of a defense
character,” a Russian foreign ministry spokesman
said on November 6, adding that Turkey’s exercises
“do not facilitate the search for a comprehensive
solutions to the years old Cyprus
problem.”
Commonwealth Concerned Over Turkish
Threats
The Commonwealth Summit, in its final
communiqué on October 27, also expressed concern over
“recent threats of use of force and integration of
the occupied territory by Turkey,” reiterated
support for Clerides’ demilitarization proposal,
and reaffirmed earlier calls for the withdrawal of all
Turkish forces and settlers from
Cyprus.
During the summit President Clerides conferred
with many heads of state on ways to overcome
Turkey’s intransigence and achieve progress on
Cyprus.
Clerides to Seek Second
Term
President Glafcos Clerides announced on
November 6 that he will seek a second five-year term
during February’s Presidential
elections.
The other candidates are United
Democrats’ leader and former President George
Vassiliou, DIKO leader and former President Spyros
Kyprianou, EDEK leader Vassos Lyssarides, Liberal Party
leader Nicos Rolandis, and George Iacovou, running as in
independent, supported by AKEL.
Massive Cache of Stolen Cypriot
Artifacts Found
Turkish Art Dealer Arrested in
Germany
A huge collection of over 100 pieces of ancient
and Byzantine artifacts looted from churches and
archaeological sites in occupied Cyprus were discovered
on October 14 in the Munich home of a Turkish art dealer,
Hikmet Aydin.
The icons, frescoes, ancient pottery, statues
and coins in Aydin’s possession, which were being
illegally sold on the international market had an
estimated value of $46 million.
Aydin, who has been charged with trading in
stolen artifacts, appears to have been a key player in a
systematic campaign facilitated by Turkish occupation
authorities to eradicate any trace in the occupied area
of Cyprus’ Hellenic and Byzantine cultural
heritage.
Effort to Retrieve Artifacts
Continues
“We are determined to get back any
archaeological or church treasures stolen from the
Turkish occupied areas of the island, no matter how much
time elapses,” Cyprus Attorney-General Alecos
Markides said in Nicosia on October 16. Aydin’s
arrest¾the result of a coordinated effort by the
Cypriot and German police¾is the most
dramatic development in ongoing efforts by the Cyprus
government and the Church of Cyprus to end the smuggling
and illegal sale of Cypriot artifacts on the
international art market.
Since Turkey’s 1974 invasion and
occupation of 37% of Cyprus, most, if not all of the
pieces of art in the 500 churches, monasteries, and
museums of occupied Cyprus have been stolen and illegally
sold on the world art market. These actions,
well-documented by the international media, have been
condemned by UNESCO and other international
organizations.
In 1992 Turkish art smugglers were dealt a
major setback when a U.S. District Court ruled that the
sale to an Indianapolis art dealer of four 6th century
mosaics, stolen from the Church of Kanakaria in occupied
Cyprus, was illegal and ordered the return of the mosaics
to the Church of Cyprus.
U.S. Congressional Resolution
Calls for End to Rights Violations of Cypriot
Enclaved
A resolution calling on U.S. President Bill
Clinton “to undertake efforts to end restrictions
on the freedoms and human rights of the enclaved people
of Cyprus” was introduced by Representative Ileana
Ros-Lehtinen (R-FL) in the U.S. House of Representatives
on October 29.The resolution (H. Con. Res. 181)further
urges the President to remain engaged “until the
human rights and fundamental freedoms of the enclaved
people of Cyprus are restored, respected, and
safeguarded.”
The resolution points out that the occupation
authorities routinely deny basic human rights to the 500
Greek Cypriots still living in occupied Cyprus, including
freedom of movement and limited access to mail,
newspapers, medical care, and education. A similar
resolution is expected to be introduced in the U.S.
Senate soon.
Among the original co-sponsors of the House
resolution are Representatives Robert Menendez (D-NJ),
Brad Sherman (D-CA), Michael Bilirakis (R-FL), Carolyn
Maloney (D-NY), Mike Pappas (R-NJ) and Bobby Rush
(D-IL).
Swedish Foreign Minister Lena Helm-Wallen, who
visited the enclaved in occupied Karpass in October, also
expressed her concern over their plight. The enclaved
“live a complicated life,” she said, adding
that “we in the international community have a
special responsibility” to improve their
lives.
Several thousand Greek Cypriots remained in the
occupied area immediately after Turkey’s
invasion, but their numbers have steadily declined.
A confidential 1994 U.N. report concluded that the
occupation authorities are subjecting them to inhumane
conditions in order to ethnically cleanse occupied
Cyprus. Turkey’s actions are in flagrant violation
of the 1975 Third Vienna Agreement, meant to safeguard
the rights of the enclaved.
E.U.: Turkey Must Support
Cyprus Accession
If E.U.-Turkish relations are to improve,
“the climate must change and the threats of war
must change,” E.U. Commissioner Hans Van den Broek
said on October 26.
In recent weeks European officials have
repeatedly stressed to Turkish officials that Ankara is
expected to support Cyprus’ accession to the
European Union, and to play a positive role in U.N.
efforts to achieve a comprehensive Cyprus
settlement.
British Minister of State Douglas Henderson
said on October 29 that he told Turkish officials during
a recent trip to Ankara that “ all people of Cyprus
will benefit as a result of a solution, and anything
which causes tension and puts obstacles are to be
condemned.”
Last summer the Turkish side undermined
U.N.-sponsored direct talks on Cyprus by insisting that
the Turkish side would not negotiate until the E.U.
deferred the process of Cyprus’ E.U.
accession.
Turkey’s role during the talks was
“not constructive,” Swedish Foreign Minister
Lena Hjelm-Wallen said in Nicosia on October 15, and she
expressed concern over Turkey’s threat to annex the
occupied areas.
Turkish Claims
Rejected
Three international jurists have rejected
claims by Turkey that Cyprus’ accession to the E.U.
violates the treaties establishing the Republic of
Cyprus.
“The Cyprus Republic had the right to
submit an application for accession and there is no legal
impediment in its goal to become a full member of the
European Union,” according to a recently-released
opinion by three internationally recognized legal
experts, all members of the International Law Commission.
While the provisions prevent the Republic of Cyprus from
uniting with another state, it does not prevent
“cooperation with a team of states such as the
E.U.”
The opinion reaffirms the view of the U.N.
General Assembly, the Security Council and the European
Court of Human Rights that there is no legitimate state
on Cyprus other than the internationally-recognized
Republic of Cyprus.
The legal opinion, prepared by James Crawford,
professor of International Law at Cambridge University,
his colleague at Vienna University, Gerhard Hafner, and
professor of International Law at Paris University, Alain
Pellet, was circulated as a U.N. document on
October 24.
Strong Growth of Cyprus Economy
Continues
Finance Minister Christodoulos Christodoulou
presented the proposed 1998 state budget to the Cyprus
House of Representatives on October
15.
Although the budget provides for increased
funds for several large infrastructural projects, the
government anticipates a reduction of the deficit to 3.8%
of GDP in 1997, down from a deficit of 5.5% of GDP in
1996. Inflation (3.3%) and unemployment (3.3%) are also
expected to remain low, while the economic growth rate
this year is estimated to rise to 2.5%, compared to 1.9%
last year.
Business Services a Key Economic
Sector
An increase in the number of tourists this year
and the continuing commitment of the government and
private sector promoting Cyprus as a regional business
center are major factors in the vibrant rate of economic
growth.
In 1996 the business services sector
contributed 71% of GDP, Cyprus President Glafcos Clerides
said on October 16, and “this
outstanding performance underlines our responsibilities
to preserve our competitiveness with the continuous
improvement of the level and kind of
services.”
Cyprus continues to take steps to adapt its
economy to those of the E.U. member-states and to promote
Cyprus-E.U. economic relations. In October Cyprus
participated in “Europartenariat 1997,” the
largest business-meeting program of the European Union,
aimed at strengthening cooperation among small and medium
European enterprises.
In
Brief . . .
In his message to Secretary-General Kofi
Annan on October 24, the 52nd anniversary of the
founding of the U.N., Cyprus President Glafcos
Clerides reaffirmed Cyprus’ continuing support
for U.N. principles and stressed his commitment to work
with the international community to achieve “a just
solution to our problem, based on the relevant
resolutions of the U.N. and the principles enshrined in
the U.N. Charter.”
The exhibit, “From Books to Brushes: The
Story of Cyprus Through the Eyes of its Children,”
opened at the Capital Children’s Museum in
Washington, DC, on October 29. Inaugurating the
exhibition, Ambassador Andros Nicolaides said that
through the eyes of the children “we see a
liberated outlook on the global values of freedom,
justice and equality,” as well as the
“discernible marks that have been engraved in the
children's hearts by (Turkey's) invasion, occupation and
continued division of Cyprus". The subjects of the
paintings are drawn from ancient history and mythology as
well as from the modern political turmoil of the forcible
division and foreign occupation of their country.
The exhibit of paintings, created by children 9-11 from
the village of Emba in southwestern Cyprus, will remain
open until November 30. Cyprus First Lady Lilla-Irene
Clerides has been the driving force behind this unique
exhibition, which has been displayed throughout Cyprus,
and in London and Washington. Prior to being on display
at the Children’s Museum, part of the collection
was exhibited at the World Bank.
|
The Cyprus Embassy Newsletter
is Published by the Press & Information Office of
the Embassy of Cyprus, 2211 R Street, NW, Washington
DC 20008, (202) 232-8993, (202) 234-1936 Fax. The
Cyprus Government Web site is at http://www.pio.gov.cy/
(and mirrored in the U.S. at http://www.kypros.org/
which also maintains an electronic archive of the
newsletter). |
|