Picture of Blake More
Subjunctive
by Blake More - Saturday, 5 May 2012, 10:34 PM
 

Νομἰζω ὀτι βρἰκα ἐνα δεἰγμα της υποτακτικἠς. Τουλἀχιστον ταιριἀζει την περιγραφἠ σε Holton, p. 205:

Τι καλἀ που θα ἠταν να μην ἐβρισκα εκεἰ ...

Please, someone, tell me if this is actually the case. 

Picture of Greg Brush
Re: Subjunctive
by Greg Brush - Sunday, 6 May 2012, 06:46 PM
  I'm not quite sure what Greek subjunctives have to do with your question, since your example is essentially a contrary-to-fact condition:
Τι καλά που θα ήταν να μην έβρισκα εκεί ... = How good it would be for me not to be here ... [but I am, in fact, here] -or- How good it would be if I were not here ... [but I am here]

Note that neither θα ήταν nor έβρισκα are subjunctive mood. Your example is analogous to those in Lesson 93, which deals with contrary-to-fact ("unreal") conditions, where the imperfect indicative and the conditional are used to form such sentences.

Regards,
Greg Brush
Picture of Blake More
Re: Subjunctive
by Blake More - Sunday, 6 May 2012, 07:25 PM
  Oh..........but I interpreted the sentence to mean "how good it would be not to find her there." Does the subjunctive understanding make more sense in that case?
Picture of Blake More
Re: Subjunctive
by Blake More - Sunday, 6 May 2012, 07:33 PM
 

I stupidly omitted the word   την   before   ἐβρισκα. Does it make more sense this way?

Even if it doesn't, thanks for your help.

Picture of Greg Brush
Re: Subjunctive
by Greg Brush - Monday, 7 May 2012, 02:25 AM
  Uh-h-h, yes, it makes a difference:
Τι καλά που θα ήταν να μην την έβρισκα εκεί ... = How good it would be that I didn't find her here ... -or- How good it would be for me not to find her here ...

However, some of this misunderstanding is my fault, since without the expressed object την, I mistakenly took the sense of the verb βρίσκω here to be middle, "I found myself, I was located (at)". However, active voice βρίσκω actually means "I find (something)". In any event, imperfect έβρισκα is still not subjunctive.

Regards,
Greg Brush